Skip to content
Hiring contractors: rules and duties

Plant hire agreement: standing time, breakdowns, damage and the operator, and what South African law adds

In short

A plant hire agreement sets the hire period, the rate basis, standing and breakdown time, risk of damage, insurance and who controls the operator. Under South African common law, the hirer must return the machine in the condition it was received, fair wear and tear excepted. The risk and breakdown clauses cost a hirer the most.

Tell us what plant you need

Headcore8 min read8 sources

What should a plant hire agreement include?

A plant hire agreement should state when the hire starts and ends, which idle hours are paid and who pays for breakdowns and damage. It should also say who insures the machine and who directs the operator. The Contractors Plant Hire Association's standard terms of hire for general plant (version 1, 2014) have a clause on each of these.[1]

The standard terms take precedence over any terms in the hirer's enquiry (clause 1). No variation binds either party unless it is in writing and agreed by both. A change you want, such as a cap on idle hours, therefore has to be written into the signed agreement.[1]

The same clauses apply whether you take one machine or a fleet through plant hire. Public buyers write their own conditions. George Municipality's tender ENG006/2024, which closed on 10 May 2024, shows how a buyer's terms differ from the owner's.[2]

How do the standard terms and a public buyer's terms compare?

The industry's standard terms and George Municipality's 2024 plant hire tender answer the same questions differently, most of all on idle time, breakdowns and damage.[1][2]

How do the standard terms and a public buyer's terms compare?
ClauseStandard terms of hire (CPHA, version 1, 2014)George Municipality tender ENG006/2024
Idle time from bad weatherHire charges continue (clause 4.4)Not standing time, so not paid (clause 3.2.3)
Idle time on site, machine availableHire charges continue (clause 4.4)Standing time, paid at 70% of the working-time rate (clause 3.2.3)
Breakdown caused by a defect in the plantNo charge for the downtime, if reported at once and confirmed in writing (clauses 4.4 and 8.2)Not paid as standing time (clause 3.2.3); a machine below 85% availability in any two weeks may be rejected and replaced within three days (clause 2.15.1)
Risk of loss or damagePasses to the hirer when the hire starts, whatever insurance exists (clause 12.1)The municipality is not liable unless its own proven negligence caused the damage (clause 2.12)
InsuranceThe hirer's responsibility (clause 14)The hire company insures (clause 2.6); for vehicles hired without an operator, the excess is set out in an annexure (clause 2.14)
Ending the hireWritten notice of at least a day by either party (clauses 4.2 and 4.3)One working day's notice by either party (clause 2.9)

Sources:[1][2]

Who carries the risk of damage to hired plant?

In South African law the hirer does, unless the agreement says otherwise or the hirer proves that the damage was not caused by negligence it answers for. In Mutual Construction v Komati Dam (2008, paragraph 6), the Supreme Court of Appeal held that a hirer must return a hired article "in the same condition in which it had been at the outset of the period of hire, fair wear and tear excluded".[3]

The owner only has to prove that the machine came back damaged. The hirer must then show that the damage was not caused by its negligence or that of people under its control (paragraph 6).[3]

In that case a dump truck was hired with the owner's operator, who worked under the hirer's "sole and absolute control". The operator fell asleep at the wheel. The court held that, under the contract, the hirer had accepted liability for his negligence on site (paragraphs 7, 12 and 15).[3]

The hirer was ordered to pay the owner's damages (order). The owner had claimed the cost of repair and the income lost while the truck stood (paragraph 2).[3]

What is standing time in plant hire, and who pays for a breakdown?

Standing time is paid idle time: the machine is on site and available but not working. George Municipality's 2024 tender pays it at 70% of the working-time rate. Its definition excludes servicing, breakdowns (including time waiting for spares), inclement weather, a missing operator and refuelling on a wet rate.[2]

The industry's standard terms put more of that time on the hirer. Hire charges run while plant stands idle for inclement weather, running repairs, refuelling, tyre changes or other factors beyond the owner's control (clause 4.4).[1]

A breakdown caused by a defect is free of charge only when it is reported. The hirer must report it immediately and confirm it in writing; otherwise the hirer gets no reduction in the hire rate (clause 8.2).[1]

Under the same terms, an accessory is hired separately, so its breakdown does not stop the plant's hire rate (clause 2.2). Tyre and tube damage on site is the hirer's cost unless the agreement says otherwise (clause 9).[1]

For hourly rates and how public buyers count a working shift, see TLB hire prices.[2]

Who is responsible for an operator supplied with the plant?

On a construction site, the operator must be "certified competent" and "authorised in writing to operate" the plant (Construction Regulations, 2014, regulation 23(1)(d)). The same regulation requires a medical certificate of fitness.[8]

The Occupational Health and Safety Act makes the "user" of machinery the person with "the right of control over the use" of it. The definition excludes "a lessor of" that machinery (section 1). A hire company working on your site can be a mandatary, a term that includes "a contractor or a subcontractor for work" (section 1).[7]

Section 37(2) extends the presumption of section 37(1) to a mandatary, "except if the parties have agreed in writing to the arrangements and procedures between them". The OHS Act page covers what that written agreement contains.[7]

Does the Consumer Protection Act apply to a company hiring plant?

Only to a small company. The Consumer Protection Act 68 of 2008 treats hire as a supply of goods (section 1). The Act does not apply where the consumer is a juristic person whose asset value or annual turnover reaches the Minister's threshold (section 5(2)(b)).[4]

Government Notice 294 of 1 April 2011 set that threshold at R2,000,000, calculated on gross assets or gross annual turnover. For a company at or above either figure when it signs, the Act does not apply to the hire. Sections 60 and 61, on recalls and liability for damage caused by goods, still apply (section 5(5)).[5]

The Act also does not apply to goods supplied to the State (section 5(2)(a)), so a municipality hiring plant is outside it whatever its size.[4]

Can a court reduce a penalty clause in a hire agreement?

Yes. A South African court may reduce a penalty "out of proportion to the prejudice suffered by the creditor" to what it considers equitable (Conventional Penalties Act 15 of 1962, section 3).[6]

A penalty stipulation makes a party liable to pay a sum for a breach of contract, as a penalty or as liquidated damages (section 1). The owner cannot recover both the penalty and damages for the same breach (section 2(1)).[6]

The standard terms let the owner cancel on any breach and take back the plant. The owner may then recover all money for "the full and unexpired hire period" (clause 19). Section 4 of the Act treats a clause keeping a party liable after withdrawal as a penalty stipulation.[1][6]

What to put in your request

  • The machine, its size and attachments, the work it will do and the site address.[1]
  • The hire period: when it starts (leaving the depot or arriving on site), the expected end date and the notice to end it.[1][2]
  • Wet or dry hire, and whether the rate covers the operator, fuel, servicing, repairs and insurance.[2]
  • Standing time: whether idle hours are paid, at what share of the working rate, and which causes are excluded.[2][1]
  • Breakdowns: how to report one, that downtime from a defect is not charged, and a replacement machine within a stated number of days.[1][2]
  • Risk and insurance: when risk passes, who insures the machine, and the excess payable on a claim.[1][2][3]
  • The operator's certificate of competence, written authorisation and medical certificate of fitness, and who directs the operator on site.[8][3]
  • Transport and establishment: who arranges it, how it is priced, and who carries the risk in transit.[1][2]
  • The written arrangements under section 37(2) of the Occupational Health and Safety Act.[7]

Questions buyers ask

Do I pay plant hire when it rains?

Under the industry's standard terms, yes: hire charges continue while plant stands idle for inclement weather (clause 4.4). George Municipality's 2024 tender excluded inclement weather from paid standing time. The agreement you sign decides, so state it there.[1][2]

Who pays if the hire company's operator damages the machine?

The agreement decides. In Mutual Construction v Komati Dam (2008), the contract put the operator under the hirer's control. The Supreme Court of Appeal held that his negligence on site counted as the hirer's under that contract, so the hirer was liable.[3]

Is a plant hire company bound by the Consumer Protection Act?

Not towards every hirer. The Act does not apply where the hirer is the State. Nor does it apply to a juristic person with assets or annual turnover of R2 million or more (Government Notice 294 of 2011).[4][5]

Tell us what plant you need

Sources

  1. Contractors Plant Hire Association (CPHA), Terms and conditions of hire (general plant), version 1, Document dated 26 March 2014.
  2. George Municipality, Bid ENG006/2024: tender for the ad hoc hire of vehicles, plants and equipment, if and when required, until 30 June 2027, Closing date 10 May 2024.
  3. Supreme Court of Appeal of South Africa, Mutual Construction v Komati Dam (466/2007) [2008] ZASCA 107, 23 September 2008.
  4. Government Gazette 32186, Consumer Protection Act 68 of 2008, 29 April 2009.
  5. Department of Trade and Industry (Government Gazette 34181), Determination of threshold in terms of the Consumer Protection Act, 2008 (GN 294), 1 April 2011.
  6. Government Gazette Extraordinary, Conventional Penalties Act 15 of 1962, 16 March 1962.
  7. Government Gazette 14918, Occupational Health and Safety Act 85 of 1993, 2 July 1993.
  8. Department of Labour (Government Gazette 37305), Construction Regulations, 2014 (GN R.84), 7 February 2014.